Wednesday, January 31, 2024

Russian 677 Lada Submarine Kilo Replacement: a super stealth winner or poor looser?

Lada class sub brief - Old style design submarine

@SubBrief Aaron  Amick

We did a lot of research on this one because there's not a lot of public information on this lesser-known Russian submarine  

Our Story begins really in 1987. The cold war is really at its peak. This is right before the five-year or so decline to the end of the Soviet Union and they're just going all out with their spending coming up with new ideas. A lot of the money at the end of the Soviet Union was really put into rocket technology and missiles and things like that, but they also put a lot of money into the Navy and one of the new ideas was to get away from nuclear propulsion for our submarines because conventional is cheaper for one and we can get a lot of performance out of these diesel conventionally powered submarines and that spurred on this idea part of which was from the kilo.

The kilo class conventionally powered submarine was a major success for the Soviet navy. They built a ton of those boats and they improved to modernize them over and over again to where they were going to be very well. The kilo is absolutely famous for being an outstanding sub and this submarine the lot of submarine that nobody knows about is the replacement for the kilo

This is the new kilo. This is the new super stealth sub that is entering Russian Service as of this year and nobody knows about it, so that's what we're going to fix today. We're going to tell you about this new sub and what a hunk of junk it is. The reason why it's so secret is they're embarrassed to tell anybody about it. This is a complete train wreck from design to construction to sea trials that nearly killed people on board. It's a mess This submarine was designed by the very respected Ruben Central Design Bureau. Now they have a ton of successes under their belt. They've built every major nuclear submarine for the Russian Navy and a couple submarines that were not nuclear, as well designed them including the kilo class so they can design Subs. But something went terribly wrong with this one.

Designed around a unique implementation of air-independent propulsion (AIP) technology, the new Project 677 Lada submarines were meant to provide the Russian navy with a modernized, cost-efficient complement to nuclear-powered submarines. But the Lada project stalled amid technical difficulties, leading the manufacturer to abandon AIP propulsion altogether in favor of a traditional diesel-electric system. Project 677’s place on the looser list is a reflection of the fact that the Russian shipbuilding industry has failed to implement the submarines’ core defining feature, dooming what was a potentially innovative class to long-term technical irrelevance.

 

Russia's AIP-powered Lada-class submarines: A significant advancement in non-nuclear underwater warfare 

Russia's Lada-class submarines, also known as Project 677, utilize air-independent propulsion (AIP) technology, setting them apart as the first class of AIP-powered submarines in the Russian Navy. This technological leap allows for underwater operations without the need for atmospheric oxygen, enhancing their stealth capabilities and effectiveness in anti-submarine warfare. 

Improvements over the Kilo-class submarines include better acoustic signatures, advanced combat systems, a mono-hull design, increased speed, and reduced surface displacement for maneuverability. Lada-class submarines are equipped with modern sonar systems, automated combat control, and countermeasure electronic support. 

Despite initial plans to replace older Kilo-class submarines, construction of additional Improved Kilo-class boats has been ordered due to setbacks with the Lada-class program. Overall, the development and implementation of the Lada-class submarines represent a significant advancement in non-nuclear underwater warfare technologies.

Developer: Stealth Capabilities of 677 Lada Subs Outshine Its Predecessors

Visitors look at St Petersburg diesel electric submarine of the Lada class at the International Maritime Defense Show in St Petersburg. File photo - Sputnik International, 1920, 31.01.2024

The 677 Lada-class diesel-electric submarines are designed for reconnaissance, surveillance, anti-submarine warfare, anti-shipping, and mine-laying missions. The subs are equipped with advanced technology, including improved stealth capabilities, enhanced communication systems, and advanced torpedoes.

The stealth capabilities of the Project 677 Lada non-nuclear submarines are significantly superior to those of their predecessors, said Igor Vilnit, general director of the submarine's developer, the Rubin Central Design Bureau of Marine Engineering.

The first serial-produced Project 677 Lada submarine, the Kronstadt, built at the Admiralty shipyards in St. Petersburg, is being readied for delivery to the Russian Navy.

"In terms of stealth parameters, this submarine is several times superior to its predecessors. The boat maintains an extremely low noise level thanks to its specially designed equipment. Additionally, it extensively incorporates modern acoustic protection equipment, an external anti-hydrolocation coating, and carefully designed hull contours to ensure low visibility," Vilnit said in an interview.
"I would like to emphasize the hydroacoustics of the Lada: it is not only a wider range of acoustic waves, it is a significantly longer range of target detection. It took a lot of effort to achieve this result," Vilnit specified.
Mozhaisk Submarine Joins Russian Pacific Fleet - Sputnik International, 1920, 28.11.2023
Military
New Submarine Joins Russian Pacific Fleet

Lada-Class: Russia's Failed Diesel Submarine (No One Will Buy It)

by Peter Suciu Follow PeterSuciu on Twitter L

In July, the Project 677 Lada-class (NATO reporting name "St. Petersburg") diesel-electric submarine Kronstadt completed a deep-sea immersion as part of its continuing sea trials, within the maritime ranges of the Baltic Fleet.

The submarine crew verified the functioning of all onboard mechanisms and systems, practicing control algorithms at great depths and under various surfacing conditions, Naval Recognition reported at the time.

During the sea trials, the Kronstadt reached a depth of 180 meters at one of the Baltic Fleet's ranges, while the dive was facilitated by fleet forces and resources, including the rescue ship SS-750. The results of the submarine's dive were reported to the Commander-in-Chief of the Russian Navy, Nikolay Yevmenov.

Lada-Class: The Slow Boat

Construction of the Kronstadt – the first serial submarine of Project 677, following the Sankt Peterburg – began in July 2005 but was suspended by the Ministry of Defense of the Russian Federation in 2009 until 2013.

The submarine was only launched in 2018, and it took until the end of 2021 for the boat to commence its sea trials, which were prolonged due to ongoing modernization.

The submarine had been scheduled to join the Russian fleet this year, yet, there have been no reports that has occurred. When the Kronstadt finally enters service, it is expected to serve in the Northern Fleet, where the lead submarine of the project, Sankt Peterburg, is already in service. That decision had been announced at a conference call meeting at the Ministry of Defense in early March this year.

It was during that call that Russian Minister of Defense Sergey Shoigu confirmed that the submarine would carry Kalibr cruise missiles.

"The first issue on the agenda is the construction of the large submarine Kronshtadt that will enter service with the Northern Fleet. The ship is set to feature Kalibr cruise missiles, the latest radar, sonar and navigational systems. This will considerably boost its combat efficiency," Shoigu was quoted as saying by state media outlet Tass.

Lada-Class Key Details

Project 677 Lada-class submarines are often referred to as the fourth generation of diesel-electric submarines, developed by a Russian Rubin design bureau. It is essentially an improved version of the Kilo-class and was designed to be fitted with an air-independent propulsion (AIP) along with new combat systems. The AIP system was meant to increase submerged endurance to 45 days, while its submerged cruising range was 500 nautical miles (900 km) at three knots.

The boats have a surface displacement of about 1,750 tonnes and can develop an underwater speed of up to 21 knots, and an endurance of 45 days. The Lada-class subs are armed with Kalibr cruise missile systems along with six 533 mm torpedo tubes for a mix of 18 torpedoes or tube-launched missiles. These may include the Alfa (NATO reporting name SS-N-27 or Sizzler) multi-role cruise missiles, or Oniks (SS-N-26) anti-ship cruise missiles.

The boats reportedly have a crew of 35 including officers and sailors.

The boats were initially developed and designed to protect naval bases, coastal installations, and sea lanes from hostile submarines and ships, while these boats can also perform patrol and surveillance tasks, including anti-submarine warfare (ASW) and anti-surface warfare (AsuW) operations.

Problem-Plagued Platform

Sankt Petersburg (B-585), the lead submarine of the project, was launched in late 2004 and commissioned in 2010. However, she was not accepted by the Russian Navy as it was discovered there were issues with the boat's propulsion and that its sonar systems did not meet Russian specifications.

Construction on the remaining boats of Project 677 was thus frozen.

The issues with the lead submarine were eventually addressed, but only after several years of serving as a "test platform," she was formally accepted into service with the Russian Navy last year. Sankt Petersburg officially joined the Northern Fleet in September 2021.

Russia was unable to resolve the issues with the fuel cells for the AIP, and as a result the second boat of the class, the Kronstadt, was fitted with an ordinary diesel-electric propulsion system without the AIP system.

Currently, the Admiralty Shipyard is also building one more Lada-class submarine, the future Velikiye Luki, while the first steel was cut for the next two boats with a third also on order. Originally a full dozen of the diesel-electric boats were ordered, but given the issues with the program, it is unclear if that order has been pulled.

Export Model – With No Buyers

Russia had further developed an export variant of the Lada-class: the Project 1650 Amur-class (named for the Amur River), which was designed for markets including India and China, while Morocco has also been offered one. The export submarine could be offered in various configurations with a displacement of 550 to 1,850 tonnes and be equipped with a variety of weapon systems.

To date, there have been no buyers for the submarines, and given the problems with the boats as well as the sanctions placed on Russia, following its unprovoked invasion of Ukraine, the Amur-class could be dead in the water.

Author Experience and Expertise

Peter Suciu is a Michigan-based writer. He has contributed to more than four dozen magazines, newspapers, and websites with over 3,200 published pieces over a twenty-year career in journalism. He regularly writes about military hardware, firearms history, cybersecurity, politics, and international affairs. Peter is also a Contributing Writer for Forbes and Clearance Jobs. You can follow him on Twitter: @PeterSuciu.

Image Credit: Creative Commons. 

 

Lada Class Patrol Submarine | MilitaryToday.com

ARG

Country of origin Russia
Entered service 2010
Crew 38 men
Diving depth (operational) ~ 250 m
Diving depth (maximum) 300 m
Sea endurance 45 days
Dimensions and displacement
Length 72 m
Beam 7 m
Draught 6.5 m
Surfaced displacement 1 675 tons
Submerged displacement 2 700 tons
Propulsion and speed
Surfaced speed 10 knots
Submerged speed 20 knots
Diesel generators 2 x 3 499 hp
Electric motors 1 x 5 576 hp
Armament
Missiles Alfa (SS-N-27 Sizzler) cruise missile, Oniks (SS-N-26) anti-ship cruise missile
Torpedoes 6 x 533 mm torpedo tubes, for 18 torpedoes, anti-submarine or anti-ship missiles
Other mines in place of missiles and torpedoes

   The Project 677 or Lada class is a diesel-electric patrol submarine, developed by a Russian Rubin design bureau. It is an improved version of the Kilo class, fitted with an air-independent propulsion and new combat systems. The previous Kilo class was a basic submarine, simple in design and technology. Also it achieved respectable export sales. Its major operators are China, India and Iran. Development of the Lada class commenced in the early 1980s. It was rather protracted. The goal was to develop a submarine that would be much quieter than its predecessor. The lead boat was commissioned only in 2010. It turned out that the new boat has fallen far short of requirement.

   The lead boat was laid down at the Admiralty Shipyard in St. Petersburg in 1997 and launched in 2004. It was commissioned in 2010 and is in service with the Baltic Fleet. The Admiralty Shipyard laid down another three submarines of this class. The lead boat, Sankt Peterburg, was extensively tested by the Russian Navy, before entering service. Though it turned out that this submarine has fallen far short of requirements. The main problem was its propulsion system. Also there were a number of other major issues. Russia invested a lot of time and resources in development of the Lada class boats, however this project turned out to be a failure. One of the reasons was that after collapse of the Soviet Union a number of companies that produced various components for Soviet submarines simply closed down or stopped production of military equipment. Some of the companies ended up in independent Ukraine. So at that time Russians lacked all necessary equipment and expertise to build these new advanced boats. Between 2009-2011 construction of the follow-on boats was suspended due to multiple major issues with the lead boat. Rubin design bureau was ordered to make changes to the project. The Sankt Peterburg was used only as a test boat for testing various equipment, rather than for active duty. Incomplete boats were heavily redesigned and were built to an improved project. In 2013 construction of the second boat resumed. In 2015 construction of the third boat resumed - it was re-launched due to the redesign. However construction of the 4th boat remains suspended and there are no plans to complete it. Production of the Lada class boats was stopped in favor of more traditional Project 636 Varshavyanka (Improved Kilo) class boats. However in 2019 a contract was signed for construction of two more Lada class boats. Most likely that it included the 4th boat Petrozavodsk. In 2020 a 6th boat of the class was ordered. Interestingly the lead boat Sankt Peterburg began its active duty only in 2021. Originally it was planned that the Lada class boats will have a service life of 30 years.

   The Lada class submarines are designed to protect naval bases, costal installations and sea lanes from hostile submarines and ships. These boats can also perform patrol and surveillance tasks.

   The Lada class boats had a number of new and unusual design features. Designers abandoned a number of proven features in order to achieve better performance. These include new anti-sonar coating of the hull, which reduces acoustic signature of the boats. Submarines are fitted with sophisticated sonar equipment with bow and flank arrays, as well as towed array.

   The Lada class has six 533 mm torpedo tubes for a mix of 18 torpedoes or tube-launched missiles. These include Alfa (Western reporting name SS-N-27 or Sizzler) multi-role cruise missiles, or Oniks (SS-N-26) anti-ship cruise missiles.

   This submarine class is fitted with a fuel cell plant, which gives air independent propulsion with oxygen/hydrogen fuel cells and electric/chemical generators. The Air Independent Propulsion (AIP) system increases the Lada class submerged endurance to 45 days. The submerged cruising range is 500 nautical miles (900 km) at 3 knots. However it appeared that design of the Russian AIP was rather raw and had numerous problems. Notably the fuel cells were poor. Russia could not develop more advanced fuel cells due to funding problems and lack of expertise. As a result the second boat of the class, the Kronstadt, was fitted with an ordinary diesel-electric propulsion system without the AIP system. In 2022 the second boat of the class, Kronstadt, completed factory sea trials

Variants

   Amur class, or Project 1650, a less capable version, intended for export. It is named after the Amur river. Design work has been completed for a whole family of submarines with a displacement ranging from 550 to 1 850 tons and various weapon systems.

Name Laid down Launched Commissioned Status
Sankt Peterburg (B-585) 1997 2004 2010

Active, in service

Kronstadt (B-586) 2005 2018 Expected in 2022

Sea trials

Velikiye Luki (B-587) 2006 ? Expected in 2022

Under construction

Petrozavodsk 2006 ? ?

Construction suspended

Vologda 2022 ? ?

Under construction

Yaroslavl 2022 ? ?

Under construction

 

No comments:

Post a Comment

One Ping Please - How to Use Sonar in Sea Power Naval Combat in the Missile Age - YouTube

One Ping Please - How to Use Sonar in Sea Power Naval Combat in the Missile Age - YouTube A definitive Sonar guide for Sea Power Naval Comba...